Skip to content
Main -> Dating -> How Long Is Too Long to Stay in a Relationship . Dating Advice
  • 10.04.2019
  • by Kigadal

How Long Is Too Long to Stay in a Relationship . Dating Advice

5 Signs He's Not Going to Marry You

Verified by Psychology Today. Valley Girl With a Brain. At the time, I considered this less a threat and more a way to expedite the inevitable— marriage , family, an otherwise perfect union. In her case, it had proven a successful strategy. On the final day of the ultimatum, he presented me not with a ring and a proposal, but the promise of one day soon.

After 5 years with no proposal, it might be time for an ultimatum. A link has been sent to your friend's email address. A link has been posted to your Facebook feed. Please read the rules before joining the discussion. Dear Amy: Shortly after meeting my boyfriend five years ago, I moved into his apartment and we are very happy together. He is a hard-working and caring person — the man I want to spend the rest of my life with. Getting married has always been very important to me, and I always hoped that moving in together was a step in that direction.

However, five years later, he has yet to propose and, though I often bring up the prospect of marrying someday, he never has much to say.

Okay here I Okay me and my boyfriend have been dating for 5 years he is 28 and I am We just got a house together and our. I Resented Him For Not Proposing After Six Years, So I Said No When He Did of woman who's going to be your girlfriend for like five years,” she said. a man for more than 10 years (they started dating in high school) and. After five years of dating, I told my boyfriend that if he didn't propose by No one can—except maybe someone who's going through it too.

Why the wait, when he knows how I long for it? I turned 30 this year and always imagined myself married with kids by now.

Dating five years no proposal

How can I gently nudge him to propose? You bring up the topic of marriage often. Surely he has become skilled at the artful dodge. You mentioned that Jen shouldn't give her boyfriend an ultimatum.

Yet, she should plan her next move without telling him if he doesn't ease her worries. If they've been together for years, why would she do something like that? The interesting point here is, even if she did plan a move without telling him, and the decision was to leave the relationship, her boyfriend will still find himself faced with an ultimatum. Either he accepts that she's gone or he goes after her and asks her to marry him IF she's willing to take him back.

I felt you gave pretty wise advice up until you mentioned planning an important relationship decision between her and her boyfriend without him knowing anything about it. It's not about the ultimatum being terrorism. It's about informing the other partner that you can no longer afford to priortise them in your life if they won't commit to you. And I'm not saying that in a judgemental way! So far from it. I had children without being married and although I was very relieved I could walk away from his selfishness without additional bureaucracy, his initial reluctance to get married just painted a general picture.

Later, years later, I fell for a man who was very present in my life, kind, supportive, funny, the perfect boyfriend, except, he didn't want to label it etc, so I walked away. I missed him but I felt clarity afterwards, and he did not come after me. I won't be anybody's grey area now.

That leads to being single a lot! But still, don't let yourself be parked in a grey area. I understand how this dilemma feels. When you love someone so much you will sacrifice your principles for them- you know you're in for some sleepless nights one way or another.

I was in a ltr a year ago that ended because I kept pushing for a commitment. I felt that I was seeking an answer to some unspoken questions more than anything. I wanted to know how devoted my partner was to me.

I wanted to know if I could depend on him being there if I was going through tough times- or when I aged - or if we had relationship problems I couldn't tell BC he was really emotionally unavailable and he became upset when we had to discuss anything that involved conflict or commitment. I've learned that my need for commitment is valid and manditory in a LTR.

I only want to be with someone who isn't using me as a place holder while the search continues for the "next" best thing That person broke my heart because I wasn't important enough to him- even After all the good times we shared.

He took up with a much younger woman soon after. I hope she doesn't waste too much time on someone so fickle and broken. Follow your heart even if it means living through a broken heart - it is always right. As the child of a couple who decided to never marry well, my dad married my mom 7 mos. My Father's death has been pure hell for my Mom and not just because he isn't around anymore.

They were together 52 years. Try telling that to lawyers when one dies without a will and there you are with a marriage certificate a whole 7 months old. No social security. You have to be married at least a year. Everything was separate. This has been hell for me and I wish he would have married her years ago so this would have been hers without all the mess. It is a selfish decision for a man to reap all the benefits of marriage without the legal responsibilities of a wife. A man who won't protect the woman he loves with that piece of paper has never really considered what may happen after they have played house without the legal binding.

It is truly a mess. I will tell you after the experience of my own parents, this would have never been an option for me. If my husband had not married me, he would have lived without me. Yes, I am bitter. Had an entire childhood if this. Ladies, do what you will, but please leave children out of it. People do need to be aware of said realities. So many are under the impression that once they live together for x amount of years - they will be considered "common law".

Not so - at least in the USA. Only a small handful of states recognize common law, and no amount of living together can compensate for the laws that govern marriage, laws of survivorship, etc.

The legal act of marriage opens up benefits and entitlements that are not realized with living together. People need to make informed decisions whether they chose to marry or not and the long term impacts of either choice. Sad thing is, women these days seem to be ok living with a man and acting like a wife thinking it is the natural path to marriage. It's often not. Then it becomes a why buy the cow when you get the milk for free situation. And then the years pass and the wondering never ceases.

Being denied marriage is like a rejection, especially when one person wants it and the other person doesnt. I dont believe any person should have to deny themselves marriage or change their beliefs on it because of their partner. If it is something you truely believe needs to happen to live your relationship to its fullest potential than stand your ground.

I agree with wild idea. Why are women in still so dependent on the man to be the one to have to 'decide' and determine if the couple is going to get married or not and the woman is then left 'waiting'? This does not make sense in our time era. It seems like an archaic, patriarchal system and that it would be helpful for women to update it. I do not agree that marriage is just a piece of paper.

To myself and many couples I know it is a symbol of eternity. Sure divorce rates are high but I don't think most people commit to marriage with that in mind. If a partner can't commit to the next legal step then it is time to examine why and make an exit plan if you aren't okay with the reasons. Two questions to consider: 1 Why do you want to be married?

You two are not in love. If both of you cannot resolve something this meaningful to you, how can you expect to survive marriage? But why would the guy marry any of the ladies from these stories if she is with him nevertheless? Of course you should leave him, you clearly don't have love for him and how could he respect you if you won't follow through your 'promise'? He will never make that investment since he has you for free anyways.

I know I'm probably being hasty but my boyfriend is 5 years younger than me. So, I had to ask if he had any plans for the future, our future. He was the first to talk about marriage, hinting about it even. It came as a shock to me because I've stopped believing in marriage or even dreaming about it. I asked him quite straightforwardly if he wanted to marry me. I tried to get over my issues with marriage and opened up to the idea again. He still talks about it so I got encouraged.

Then the talk of babies came. All of a sudden he didn't want to talk about both marriage and babies. It alarmed me. I guess it was bad that i kept pressing him about it. But i found out some horrible truths. He made me hope for things he didn't want to actually commit to. He was just entertaining the idea. Yes, he's dating to find a wife but apparently, I'm not her.

He talked of options. It didn't help that his mother gave him a little "pep talk". Or so he called it. The entire thing questioned my ability to keep a marriage. My position in the family, middle child, and the relationship I had with my parents. It wasn't really all that warm and good.

We're pretty distant. And I'm not talking about physical distance. By now, I was frustrated. I tried ending it with him but he still doesn't want to for reasons that frustrated me even more. There's no more reason to try and work it out. He still wants to drag the relationship on anyway. I don't know anymore.

No proposal after 11 years of dating. how long should I wait? you all in one hour than your significant other does in five to ten years of dating or marriage.

I would say take a time-out and explore if you are okay with continuing with the current state of your relationship. Until you decide that you are, you won't be happy.

There is no point in trying to change his mind, because that is totally in his hands and not within your control. So your only choice to be happy is that either you accept the status quo now or don't, and then you leave the rest to destiny. But to get clarity on that I feel that people first-and-foremost need space for self-reflecting. I am so disappointed. I read this site since a long time already and I can't believe my eyes reading this article. Relationship is always a matter of choice from both parties.

If you are looking for something you don't get, share your expectations, but do not threaten someone into marriage.

Dating five years and no proposal? Time for ultimatum

If it does not happen within the time you would expect, leave. How would you feel when it happens after such a scenario? How will you feel years later knowing what brought you into that marriage? How long do you think such type of commitment will last?

My boyfriend and I met and fell in love in summer , so it's been almost 5 years. Anyways, I told him that I rather get married than have a free union thing. Anyways, when I told him I rather get married he said okay, we can do that some day. If I had a strong desire to be married, and I was in a relationship for five years with no sign of a proposal in sight, I might start getting restless. At least that's what I told my now husband on year five of our dating Meanwhile, my husband was enjoying our dating relationship, felt no urge to get . And when he finally did propose, I never doubted his sincerity for a.

Women don't always want to commit either! I was one of them. In a relationship with a man for 8 years who constantly wanted to get married and I didn't I just wasn't ready. He finally moved on and it was sad but I understood he wanted more than I could provide.

I eventually did get married but not until I was You shouldn't be afraid of giving an ultimatum but you do need to follow it through.

The proper way would be not to say "If you don't marry me I'm going to leave you" but say "I want to get married in the next year or whatever timeframe is exceptable to you". And then take it from there. You're the exception, honey. This article is not about you.

This article is about women who WANT to get married. Think outside yourself, ok? Doesn't this piece clearly show how patriarchal our societies are. Things like outlook on marriage and kids should be discussed if a relationship gets more serious.

I never wanted kids.

After 5 years with no proposal, it might be time for an ultimatum. How long should you remain in a dating relationship without it moving to engagement I personally know several couples who dated for five years or more and finally did get .. He talks about the future, but still no proposal. Looking for years and began dating 3 years and still no proposal decker may reflect growing trends in the m-word, marriage. He's not a commitment. If you wait .

If a guy did, there was no point in a relationship - I certainly didn't want him to compromise his desires and I knew unequivocally that I didn't want them. Ditto with a man with young children. I dated a man who had issues with marriage - gave it some time bc sometimes a relationship can change a perspective.

I never gave an ultimatum, just said I'm looking to share something he didn't value. Loved him but loved myself more. A relationship is about shared values. If you don't value the same things that are significant, why bother?

Keep the person in your life who is your best friend and with you on a daily basis. Marriage is only paper. However, if they are not with you on a daily basis.

I spent 17 years with my best friend who did marry me. He was with me all the time. Everyone just accepted that we were married because we were that close. I would wait another 17 years if I could he passed away of lung cancer. The point is. I was blessed to be with my best friend, love of my life for 17 years! If they are not your best friend, leave them and find your best friend. When my boyfriend and I met he spoke of marriage right away which at first scared me.

We were very happy together and I already felt I had met the love of my life but I felt it was an early mention at three weeks of dating. He mentioned marriage and brought it up lightly to my now growing delight over the first two years we lived together but now does not bring it up at all.

I'm now the one who tries to discuss it because I want to marry him and am growing tired of supporting him emotionally daily he has bad anxiety and visiting his family every summer without being his wife.

He is now apprehensive about marriage and feels we have problems and issues to work on before considering marriage. In contrast, I accept our arguments and differences, his and my personal issues and I want to marry him as we are, imperfect but in love, loving and supportive of one another. He doesn't feel comfortable even broaching the subject of marriage now.

I feel increasingly sad all of the time. Finding this thread was very helpful as I suspect I know the answer to my question. Can I stay in a relationship almost four years now with someone who perhaps doesn't see me as the One?

My self esteem seems to have decreased and my overall feeling of well-being in myself within the context of our live-in relationship. But I feel strong and happy with my friends and family. I didn't think marriage was important to me but I now realize my everyday role as wife without being his wife. I believe I have answered my own question but I'll post this here for discourse's sake. I should add that I've only brought it up subtly but have just recently become impatient and voiced my desire to marry more clearly.

He has made plans to spend a month with his family this summer, preferring that I come but will travel alone otherwise, and I feel we should be making future plans together. I need to be able to envision a future. I will never understand men. Its a game for them. I got to a point where I had enough and told him perhaps its time we both start seeing others. I do not have to live out of suitcases weekend after weekend you know.

I mean lets get real. Why should I do this? No women has a right to anything in the event something goes wrong. So he can get all free for the time being? I actually started to distance myself now and he picked up on this now I am good enough for phone calls etc. He says he doesnt want to loose me oh ja? Then tell me WHAT does he want? A side burner each time he needs one? And me? I think the best is to keep quiet and to start distancing oneself and just like that disappear from his life for good.

Well that is the plan for soon. Let him then get old by himself. Let me assure all women out there WE are the prize not the other way around. I know this sounds heartless, but let them then suck it up as most come around like this one once they SEE you are not around so much anymore.

You've Been in a Relationship For Almost 5 Years, Should He Propose

They have excuses, well we can TOO dish out some nasty excuses. Long gone are the days women NEED men for financial support. Our relationship was going so well and he asked me to move in with him so quickly he had never lived with anyone before even though he has long term relationships beforehe told me I'm the love of his life, I met his friends and family quickly and that one time we were in a jewelry museum and he asked me which of the rings I liked stupid me thought of a proposal, I guess he just didn't mean anything with that question.

Anyways, when I told him I rather get married he said okay, we can do that some day. After several discussions though, we went to a jewelry store to look at wedding bands for both of us. He even tried one on without me having to ask him to and seemed in a very good mood. That was around Octoberafter over three years of dating. I thought a proposal would come soon. The months afterwards, the topic was dropped completely.

Like two of his friends sent us wedding invitations and when he saw them he said something like 'I can't believe he's getting married. That's so stupid' and 'He always said he would never get married, I don't understand why he changed his mind'. One day in January I called him out on it, and we started fighting. To sum it up, he told me that he never wanted to get married and that he thinks it's stupid and that he doesn't see the point of it.

He says it's just a piece of paper and since he's not religious he doesn't see why he should do it. It ended with me leaving, and with us breaking up. FYI again, I'm not religious either, but to me, you don't have to be religious to get married.

Marriage to me is much more than a piece of paper, and I've explained that to him. Also, I know he cannot be scared for money reasons. I've always told him that I don't even need an engagement ring or a wedding, that I would be perfectly fine with us eloping a simple nice ceremony with the two of ussome wedding rings and telling everyone afterwards that we got married. Soooo we broke up and I moved out.

No contact for five months. He then drunk messages me telling me that he still loves me and misses me so much. I answer him, but I don't tell him the same thing. I just made small talk instead, I was still so hurt from all that. Then I stopped answering he didn't ask me anything so I didn't see the point of continuing to talk to him.

No contact for another few months. Then, in October last year, he reaches out to me, saying that he knows it was his fault and that I'm the love of his life and that he misses me so much and wants me back. I agreed to meet him, and we talked. He basically said the same thing again, and I told him that I've really missed him too, but that I haven't changed my mind about marriage. He said he knows that. I asked him if that means marriage is in the cards for us and he said for me, he'll do it.

I took him back, but I didn't move back in yet. He wants me too, and even though I'm at his our old apartment all the time, I still haven't given up my own apartment.

I don't want to, until we're engaged at least. I haven't said that to him yet, but I will. So we've been back together for almost six months now. Christmas, Valentine's day and my birthday came and went and we literally haven't talked about getting married again.

Not even one word. I hoped he would bring it up, but he did not. I don't know what to do. I just don't understand why he seems that much against marriage or marrying me.

His parents have been married for over thirty years and I swear they're one of the happiest couples I've ever seen. His childhood was amazing, according to him.


3 thoughts on “How Long Is Too Long to Stay in a Relationship . Dating Advice

  1. I advise to you to come on a site where there is a lot of information on a theme interesting you. Will not regret.

  2. I apologise, but, in my opinion, you are not right. I am assured. Write to me in PM, we will discuss.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top